We Are Americans
October 6, 2025 In a bold—if polarizing—pivot for the DC Universe, James Gunn’s HBO Max series Peacemaker has plunged into controversy with its second season, unleashing a dystopian alternate Earth where Nazis rule a whitewashed America. The show’s audacious plot twist, revealed in Episode 6, “Ignorance Is Chris,” has drawn sharp criticism for allegedly equating fascism with Christianity, prompting widespread accusations of tone-deaf satire and calls for a viewer boycott.The uproar centers on the series’ depiction of Earth-X, a grim parallel universe inspired by DC Comics lore where Axis powers triumphed in World War II. Here, protagonist Christopher “Peacemaker” Smith (John Cena) discovers a seemingly idyllic world—until the facade crumbles. The all-white populace, overt Nazi symbolism, and racial hostility toward characters of color, like Leota Adebayo (Danielle Brooks), expose a regime of unchecked supremacy. But it’s the subsequent episode, “Like a Thief in the Night,” that has fueled the fire. Written and directed by Gunn, it features characters blithely claiming that Nazis “love Jesus,” drawing a provocative line between religious fervor and fascist ideology. Critics argue this not only mocks Christianity but mirrors real-world America in a way that’s inflammatory and unsubstantiated.”James Gunn’s need to Nazify America and smear Christians as Jesus-loving Nazis is loathsome,” fumed Gary Buechler of Nerdrotic in a recent podcast, echoing sentiments from conservative outlets. The episode’s dialogue explicitly parallels the alternate Earth with our own, with one character quipping that the Nazi regime feels “just like home.” This has struck a nerve amid heightened cultural divides, especially post-2024 elections, where perceptions of political extremism run high. Social media erupted, with #BoycottPeacemaker trending on X, amassing over 50,000 posts in 48 hours. Users decried the show as “anti-Christian propaganda,” with one viral thread accusing Gunn of alienating his core audience ahead of his Superman directorial debut.Gunn, who co-heads DC Studios, has fired back unapologetically. In a GQ interview, he dismissed detractors as “racists” and embraced the backlash: “I’m okay with being polarizing if it means telling the truth about racism and letting bigots fall to the wayside.” He defended the Nazi reveal as a “fearless critique,” foreshadowed by diverse casting cues and historical nods, insisting the humor underscores the horror rather than glorifies it. Gunn highlighted private test screenings where audiences clocked the all-white extras early, proving the twist’s intentionality. Yet, even supporters like Comic Book Club’s analysis note Gunn’s tendency to “approach heavy issues then back away,” questioning if the satire lands meaningfully or just provokes.The controversy isn’t isolated. Peacemaker Season 2, which premiered August 21, already courted buzz with Cena’s bisexual orgy scene and ties to Gunn’s broader DCU arc, including a Lex Luthor cameo by Nicholas Hoult. No Superman appearance—despite David Corenswet’s reported disappointment—keeps the focus on Peacemaker’s emotional redemption amid chaos. HBO reports strong viewership, with Episode 6 topping charts, but the rift is palpable. Faith-based groups like the American Family Association have urged members to cancel subscriptions, labeling it “blasphemous.”As the season hurtles toward its finale, the debate rages: Is Gunn’s vision a vital mirror to societal ills, or a self-sabotaging overreach? For now, Peacemaker embodies its tagline—”In what world is he the hero?”—forcing viewers to confront uncomfortable truths. Whether this sparks a lasting boycott or cements Gunn’s provocative legacy remains to be seen. One thing’s certain: in Gunn’s DCU, neutrality is off the table.
References:
